Suppose you wanted to know which mountains stand head and shoulders above their surroundings rather than just have a high summit elevation with little rise above a ridge connecting them to a higher peak. You would first need to decide where their feet were planted, their base elevation. One choice would be to use a method similar to that used to determine 4000-footer status, which calculates the rise from the lowest col on the highest possible route to a higher point. But instead of choosing a minimum rise and then ranking peaks with at least that rise by their summit elevations as the Four Thousand Footer Club does, you would simply order them from greatest to least rise irrespective of summit elevation.
For a full discussion of the issue of prominence see the page on Topographic Prominence on the County Highpointers web site or the Prominence website by Aaron Maizlish.
Preliminary manual attempts to produce such a list were aided immeasurably by Edward Earl who used a computer algorithm on digital elevation data to produce a tentative list of New England peaks with over 1000 feet of "prominence", which is the term he gave to this calculated rise. Unfortunately the digital elevations are taken on a grid that may not hit the actual high and low points, so the results must be adjusted manually using paper topographic maps.
The following is a list of the 50 most prominent New England peaks as obtained by Roy Schweiker and Andy Martin. Note that most of these are well known as highest in their area even if they are not among the highest in their state. As shown in the table, half the contour interval is added to peaks and saddles where the map does not give an exact elevation. The list would contain the same peaks in slightly different order if "clean" prominence was used.
Peak | Prom | Peak Elevation | Peak Quad | Saddle Elevation | Saddle Location | Saddle Quad |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mount Washington | 6150 | 1916.6m | Mount Washington | 138 | Champlain Canal | Fort Ann NY |
Baxter Peak, Katahdin | 4292 | 5267 | Mount Katahdin | 970+5 | 2 places | Mud Pond |
Mount Mansfield | 3643 | 4393 | Mount Mansfield | 740+10 | Rte.100 | Stowe |
Mount Lafayette | 3360 | 5240+20 | Franconia | 1880+20 | Crawford Notch | Crawford Notch |
Killington Peak | 3325 | 4235 | Killington Peak | 900+10 | Rte.14 | Brookfield |
Sugarloaf Mountain | 3180 | 4240+10 | Sugarloaf Mountain | 1060+10 | NH Rte.110 | Milan, NH |
Equinox Mountain | 3060 | 3840+10 | Manchester | 780+10 | Rte.7 | Manchester |
Jay Peak | 2975 | 1175.9m | Jay Peak | 269.2m | Rte.14 | Caspian Lake |
Mount Moosilauke | 2932 | 4802 | Mount Moosilauke | 1870 | Kinsman Notch | Mount Moosilauke |
Bigelow, West Peak | 2855 | 4145 | The Horns | 1280+10 | Col S | Sugarloaf Mountain |
Dorset Peak | 2840 | 3760+10 | Dorset | 920+10 | Rte.30 | Manchester |
Carter Dome | 2814 | 4832 | Carter Dome | 612+3m | Pinkham Notch | Mount Washington |
Old Speck Mountain | 2720 | 4160+10 | Old Speck Mountain | 1440+10 | Dunn Notch | B Pond |
Mount Cabot | 2664 | 4160+10 | Stark | 456+3m | US Rte.2 | Mount Washington |
White Cap Mountain | 2624 | 3654 | Big Shanty Mountain | 1020+10 | NortheastCove | Lobster Mountain |
Coburn Mountain | 2520 | 3720+10 | Enchanted Pond | 1200+10 | Whipple Pond | Attean Pond |
Mount Greylock | 2482 | 3487 | Cheshire | 1000+5 | Rte.8 | Pittsfield East |
Worcester Mountains | 2472 | 3642 | Stowe | 1160+10 | Rte.105 | Spectacle Pond |
Saddleback Mountain | 2446 | 4120 | Saddleback Mountain | 1674 | Redington Pond | Redington |
Kinsman, South Peak | 2418 | 4358 | Lincoln | 1920+20 | Franconia Notch | Franconia |
Stratton Mountain | 2411 | 1201m | Stratton Mountain | 462+3m | Rte.103 | Mount Holly |
Traveler Mountain | 2340 | 3540+10 | The Traveler | 1200+10 | Pogy Notch | Wassat- Lake |
Mount Shaw | 2340 | 2990 | Melvin Village | 640+10 | Red Hill Pond | Center Sandwich |
Snow Mountain | 2330 | 3960 | Chain of Ponds | 1620+10 | Rte.16 | Quill Hill/Sadd- Mountain |
Mount Ascutney | 2290 | 954+3m | Mount Ascutney | 840+10 | Col W | Cavendish |
Kibby-Caribou Mountain | 2264 | 3654 | Kibby
Mountain
[Caribou] |
1380+10 | Mon.424 | Louise Mountain |
Mount Carrigain | 2240 | 4680+20 | Mount Carrigian | 2440+20 | Zealand Notch | Crawford Notch |
Baldpate, East Peak | 2238 | 3780+10 | Old Speck Mountain | 1552 | Grafton Notch | Old Speck Mountain |
East Mountain | 2227 | 3438 | Seneca Mountain | 366+3m | Rte.14 | Woodbury |
Grass Mountain | 2199 | 3109 | Arlington | 900+10 | Rte.7A | Bennington |
Baker Mountain | 2191 | 3521 | Number Four Mountain | 1320+10 | Big Lyford Pond | Hay Mountain |
Smarts Mountain | 2188 | 3238 | Smarts Mountain | 1040+10 | Rte.25 | Warren |
Monadnock Mountain | 2169 | 960+3m | Monadnock Mountain | 980+10 | Rte.4 | Mount Cardigan |
Cold Hollow Mountains | 2165 | 1014+3m | Cold Hollow Mountains | 354+3m | Rte.118 | Hazens Notch |
Signal Mountain | 2140 | 3360+10 | Knox Mountain | 372+3m | Rte.5 | Sutton |
Mount Ellen | 2132 | 4083 | Mount Ellen | 1951 | Elbow Rd. | Pico Peak |
Big Moose (Squaw) Mountain | 2124 | 3194 | Big Squaw Pond | 1060+10 | Col SE | Big Squaw Pond |
Mount Kearsarge | 2100 | 2920+10 | Andover | 820+10 | Col SW | Bradford |
Doubletop Mountain | 2079 | 3489 | Doubletop Mountain | 1400+10 | Black Spruce Bog | Nesow- Lake |
Elephant Mountain | 2062 | 3772 | Metallak Mountain | 1700+10 | Summit RR | Houghton |
Mount Osceola | 2040 | 4320+20 | Mount Osceola | 2280+20 | Mad R Notch | Mount Osceola |
Boundary Bald Mountain | 2002 | 3620+10 | Boundary Bald Mountain | 1628 | Mon. 397 | Boundary Pond |
Gore Mountain | 1994 | 3332 | Norton Pond | 1325+12 | 5 S of Lindsay Lake | Coaticook PQ |
Mount Cardigan | 1922 | 3155 | Mount Cardigan | 1233 | Rte.118 | Mount Cardigan |
Big Spencer Mountain | 1916 | 3206 | Big Spencer Mountain | 1280+10 | Second Roach Inlet | Farrar Mountain |
Camels Hump | 1873 | 4083 | Huntington | 2200+10 | Huntington Gap | Mount Ellen |
Belknap Mountain | 1872 | 2382 | West Alton | 520+10 | Rte.11 | Alton |
Saddleback Mountain | 1848 | 2998 | Big Shanty Mountain | 1140+10 | col N | Big Shanty Mountain |
Mount Blue | 1840 | 3180+10 | Mount Blue | 1340+10 | Rte.142 | Madrid |
Moxie Mountain | 1823 | 2920+10 | Caratunk | 1107 | Col SW | Dimmick Mountain |